The Issue of McMikkyō

At Ishizuchisan Shingon Budhdism and Shugendo, we recognize the disappointment, confusion, and disillusionment many non-Japanese practitioners have faced when encountering misrepresentations and abuses in the name of Japanese Esoteric Buddhism, by wealth and fame seeking individuals domestically here in Japan or Western orientalists abroad.

We wanted to clarify that this website was created with collaboration from Chief Acharya of the sect down to it’s followers across our sect, not with the intention of it being a recruitment website for students to our school, but to protect and support Western aspirants, especially in the contexts of Shingon and Shugendō by putting good and relevant information out there of what they should expect from any normative Japanese sect.

Japanese Esoteric Buddhism is still overwhelmingly burdened by McMikkyō taking inspiration from the modern terms like McMindfulness or McDojo. The issue with these individuals is that they actively dishearten legitimate Japanese institutions as they wear robes they bought but never earned, pridefully boast titles found via shortcuts, and use the trappings of Orientalism to woo western aspirants. As a result they are actively closing more doors in more temples for Western people to get in touch with the teachings. There is an increasing prevalence of well meaning institutions to believe that Westerners simply cannot be trusted with Japanese Esoteric Buddhism and as a result close more doors for future non-Japanese.

We urge everyone to seek out Normative Shingon and Shugendō institutions in Japan. This website was also made with collaboration from both Japanese and Western practitioners who have personally been misguided and mislead from improper or exploitative Buddhist groups and individuals. We have heard from those:

  • who have been threatened for having valid criticisms.
  • strung along into costly payment structures or subscriptions, or personal profit-oriented scheme.
  • Show clear disrespect for normative Japanese and Japanese Buddhist culture by tattooing themselves with Buddhist deities, in even more orientalist means in the styles of Japanese syndicates. This fetishization of Japanese aesthetics shows insincere belief or true intention to study as it is common knowledge that Japanese institutions like Koyasan and others do not allow such individuals to be ordained and to study.
  • Were wrapped up in the fantasies of individuals who conflate martial arts, Ninja fantasies, and power seeking with the compassionate teachings of the Buddha.
  • Misled by an individual who misrepresents connection with a recognized sect or teaching authority and give dubious private ordinations and training .
  • Misrepresent normative education, for example claiming a practice lineage like Sanboin-Ryu Kenjin-Gata does not constitute belonging to a legitimate lineage line of Shingon Buddhism or Shugendo where the years of daily post kanjo study called Ichiryu denju would be done to truly be considered a recognized master or teacher. The Ryu is a practice lineage, not a school or sect in itself though many abroad are using wordplay to misrepresent as such.
  • Treat studying a lifelong Dharma gate like a weekend business school endeavor, by coming to Japan to purchase robes, finding Japanese teachers who will cut time corners for the right price, and take photographs with monks to return back to their home country and misrepresent their qualifications.
  • Concerned about a leader and their lack of a lifelong dedication to a dharma gate by collecting as many titles and traditions as they can like cheap badges or footnotes on a resume. This is especially egregious when ancient masters of all Japanese Buddhist traditions dedicated their whole lives to the mastery of even one dharma gate and didn’t treat them as mere milestones for an orientalist checklist.

Our purpose is to aid sincere seekers toward Japanese schools that uphold the authentic, traditional practices, lineage lines, and education conventions the ways that generations of lineage masters have devoted their entire lives to, with humility and integrity.

We stand united as a sect and with our aiding partners across multiple sects, against all forms of abuse. We stand for those whose trust has been betrayed. We stand for proper transmission and we seek to lead by example.

We will not name individuals or organizations and in fact are speaking to a massive issue across many troubling groups and individuals domestic and abroad that actually prolong the proper transmission of these traditions to the west as more and more Sincere Japanese leaders in many sects see the appropriation of the dharma by individuals with motives of Orientalism, fetishization of Japanese culture, and seeking of financial gain and power.

We state that the Dharma is a path of compassion, not one of treating one’s earnest students like ignorant resources to be used.
It is a life of humility, not accumulation or delusions of orientalist grandeur.
It is a way of service, not exploitation of sincere seekers for personal gain.

If you resonated with this message please look at Karuna Mitra an organization founded by our sect and Portland Oregon’s Henjyo-ji chief Ajari, Kosho Finch. https://karunamitra.org

Share the Post: